Bragg Underground
heart and soul of our Fort Bragg community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Bragg Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

Is a baby registry selfish?

who's talking here?

**Unique is Beautiful** 1
Mrs. Forty 1
BRAGG 1
Dirty Sexy Money 4
KAJ1931 1
Absolutdreamer 2
Gizzie 3
amber 1
Loud Mouth 6

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Dirty Sexy Money --- 17 years ago -

What are your thoughts? If you are in a position where you can afford to buy the things- why is a registry necessary?  

KAJ1931 --- 17 years ago -

i dont think it is selfish 

Loud Mouth --- 17 years ago -

I think that if it's your first child no. Any other I think baby showers and reigstries are tacky. 

Gizzie --- 17 years ago -

I THINK IT IS FINE.ESPECIALLY IF YOU ARE HAVING THE OPPOSITE SEX THIS TIME. 

Absolutdreamer --- 17 years ago -

I think they are fine especially if you live far away from family. They usually ask if I had one. Really I think it's a way for them to get an idea of the things you might really need. And a way to take part with baby if they aren't closeby. I also think that if there's a huge age gap b/t kids, then its fine. Not all clothes fit the age and time they were born so reusing clothes is an option but not if they don't fit and the seasons don't fall right. And definitely if it's the opposite sex! BABY showers! Not a fan! lol But registries, I say go for it. If people wanna buy for you and they ask for your registry, then why not? 

Loud Mouth --- 17 years ago -

I'm not trying to start a "fight" LOL... I'm just going to say that I had a girl with my first and boy with my second. And even then I didn't have a shower or registry... If it's your first go for it, but the reason I didn't with my second is beecause I felt like this time around I knew what I needed, had most of it and what I didn't have, I could just get myself... people still sent my little boy things, but I didn't ask... I did have a baby shower with my daughter though. 

Dirty Sexy Money --- 17 years ago -

I'm not huge on baby showers either. We are planning a Cookout after the baby is at home so everyone can see her that wants to. I live extremely close to my family- same neighborhood. I think financially times are hard on many people so the registry I'm not feeling too much. My husband and I can get everything we need for her on our own. My best friend however, insist that it's a must have. Not for me~ There will be almost a 5 year gap between my two so no hand me downs available. 

Absolutdreamer --- 17 years ago -

I only made my registry b/c family asked for it. Even just telling them over the phone wasn't good enough for some reason. I never did the registry or baby shower with my 1st. I got taken by surprise with a baby shower this time and really didn't like it lol Had the registry only b/c of fam but bought all the stuff we needed for her ourselves. 

Loud Mouth --- 17 years ago -

yeah, I didn't want the shower myself, it was a suprise, I didn't did a registry thought because everyone kept asking what I wanted (with my first) but with my second I didn't do either... whether you register or do a shower, people are going to get for you and most likely gift cards Congrats though! 

Gizzie --- 17 years ago -

I ACTUALLY HAD 2 FOR MY FISRT.FIRST ONE WAS WHEN I WAS IN PA WITH FAMILY.THEN ANOTHER WHEN WE WERE HERE WITH FRIENDS.BUT IT WASN'T LIKE A SHOWER IT WAS A PARTY WITH MALE AND FEMALE FRIENDS. 

Loud Mouth --- 17 years ago -

Well that's different when you're from somewhere else and you know, because you have friends in both areas.... I know a girl here who had one at her husbands job, one at her job, one with her "party"friends, one with her neighbors, one back home... I mean, it was just ridiculous... She is one of those who try and get everything she can for nothing..... 

amber --- 17 years ago -

I did a registry because our family ask for it then they didn't buy anything off it so it was a waste. The stuff that they have in one store they might not have in another. 

Gizzie --- 17 years ago -

MY 2ND ALSO WAS A BOY BUT I DID SAVE EVERYTHING BUT THIS TIME WHEN PEOPLE ASKED WHAT I NEEDED(YOU CAN SAY NOTHING BUT THEY WILL GET YOU STUFF ANYWAY)I SAID JUST GET ME A GIFT CARD AND I CAN WHAT I NEED OR WHEN I NEED IT.I STILL GOT STUFF BUT I DID GET GIFT CARDS.I REMEMBER EVERYONE GOT ME DIAPERS WITH 1ST AND THAT WAS A WASTE BECAUSE HE GREW TO FAST AND I ONLY LIKE A CERTAIN KIND 

Loud Mouth --- 17 years ago -

yeah gift cards are so much better or if they include a gift receipt because you could get doubles.... even with a registry no one used it so I has all kinds of the same things and no way to return or exchange them for other things... With my first I got EVERYTHING. With my second I got a few things, but neither time did I expect a thing, so it was nice. :) Or diaper cakes because it's a little of everything... 

Dirty Sexy Money --- 17 years ago -

Diaper cakes are so cute but then that would mean I'd have to have somewhat of a babyshower... NO!! LOL I can't stand those kind of women that have 20 different baby showers, get tons of crap and end up selling it all on Craigslist for a profit in the pocket. You didn't pay for the stuff so why not regift it to someone else? We are going to do a cookout, invite friends and family as a meet n greet to the little one and have activities so that my 4 y/o doesn't feel left out. Different strokes for different folks I guess. 

**Unique is Beautiful** --- 17 years ago -

i dunno about a registry it's kinda selfish to me maybe with the people that had it that i knew they were asking for the expensive stuff the stuff they couldn't afford in a life time. Maybe for stuff that would be nice to have but not nessasary. I don't like baby showers personally the small little appitizers and all the pink blue and yellow small thingys cute this cute that blah *throws up* oh and the horrible baby shower games lmao i think i rather be at a kids party acting like a kid than a baby shower any day. Oh and the same with engament parties unless it's at a night club or has the male strippers than i am game but if it's one of those boring dinner parties where everyone has to act like princesses thn thumbs down i'll think of you when i am having fun while everyones eating their little finger foods and drinking thier cheap whine oh yeah *hats off the the future bride* you party sucks so will your marriage lmao j/k 

Dirty Sexy Money --- 17 years ago -

I'm so downing the biggest margarita or daquari that I can find after I have this baby. It'll be my 'AHA' Moment 

Loud Mouth --- 17 years ago -

lol that's so funny. Even though my shower was a suprise, I found out a few days before and I freaked LOL.. I said NO GAMES! NO APPS! I WANT A COOKOUT AND BEER LOL! Of course I couldn't drink the beer, but I wanted it LOL Well what's funnier is this time, although I decided not to have a shower, I wanted a really frilly one LOL.. I know... my mom is coming down in a few weeks and I am ready for a beer myself... I don't have time to drink-EVER! With school and the kids and everything, not even one! So when she comes I told her my husband and I are going out for a couple hours LOL... 

BRAGG --- 17 years ago -

I'm not a Fan of registries,if your family asked u what u need then yeah tell them cuz is family u know.. but I dont think is right to tell people what to buy for your baby,people are going to get something anywayz. I do not think is selfish but u just dont need that. Congrats! 

Mrs. Forty --- 17 years ago -

I think it depends on your situation. If you are having a baby shower then a a registery is just helpful to let your guests know the things you need for your baby or would like. That saves you from having to return all the items later. And what if you're having a different gender than before, sometimes your family might like to know what to buy for you. In my case all my family lives out of state, so I created a registery just to give them an idea of the things I'll need b/c they all want to send a gift for the baby. This way they can purchase the item & mail it to me or even send me a gift card to get it myself. Sometimes it could be your 4th or more child & you got rid of all your baby items b/c you didn't think you'd have anymore, so people wanna help by buying you things. I really don't think a registery is tacky b/c it's up to the other person to decide whether or not to buy you something off of the registery. With my oldest I created a registery but nobody checked it so I ended up with 3 of the same thing that I had to return, so I do see how the registery can be helpful. I don't think it's right how some people say only buy me things on my registery nothing else, b/c you are at least being kind enough to buy something for their child. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Bragg Underground