Bragg Underground
heart and soul of our Fort Bragg community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Bragg Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

From NEWSMAX.com Report Question Citizenship for "Anchor Babies"

who's talking here?

~Ole Timer~ 1
YoUr MoM 2
PopsiclesandThrowbacks 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

PopsiclesandThrowbacks --- 16 years ago -

The issue of “anchor babies” — children who automatically become citizens upon their birth to illegal aliens in the United States — has become a hot topic as their numbers continue to soar.

But nearly 60 percent of Americans now oppose “birthright citizenship,” according to a Rasmussen poll, and some lawmakers are calling for legislation to end it.

House Minority Leader John Boehner says that a revision of the 14th Amendment — which forms the basis for birthright citizenship — is “worth considering.” And legal scholars including Yale Law School Prof. Peter Schuck and U.S. Court of Appeals Judge Richard Posner question whether the amendment does in fact confer citizenship on the children of illegal aliens.

The Center for Immigration Studies (CIS) has released an in-depth report on birthright citizenship that includes these disclosures:

* Each year, 300,000 to 400,000 anchor babies are born in the United States and automatically recognized as American citizens.

* Only 30 of the world’s 194 nations confer automatic citizenship on children born to illegal aliens, and just two of them are advanced economies — the United States and Canada.

* No European country has birthright citizenship.

* Over the past few decades, a number of countries have repealed birthright citizenship provisions, including the United Kingdom, Australia, India, Ireland, and New Zealand.

* The number of U.S.-born children with illegal alien parents soared from 2.3 million in 2003 to at least 4 million in 2008. Between 2001 and 2009, such births surpassed 542,000 in Texas alone.

* The Supreme Court has ruled that children born in the U.S. to permanent resident aliens are citizens, but has never decided if the rule applies to the children of aliens whose presence is illegal or temporary.

Due to birthright citizenship, the undocumented immigrant families of anchor babies can qualify for welfare benefits they would otherwise not be entitled to receive.

Also, a child born into those families has the ability “when he grows up, to legalize his parents, and also to bring into the United States his foreign-born spouse and any foreign-born siblings,” according to CIS Legal Policy Analyst Jon Feere.

“The sponsored spouse can, in turn, sponsor her own foreign-born parents and siblings, and the siblings can, in turn, sponsor their own foreign-born spouses, and so on, generating a virtually never-ending and always-expanding migration chain.”

The child born in the U.S. to illegal aliens thus forms an anchor for the legal immigration of a number of relatives — hence the term “anchor baby.”

The anchor baby phenomenon has led to the growth of “birth tourism” — pregnant women traveling to the United States to give birth on American soil.

Feere points out: “Is automatic birthright citizenship for children of all legal and illegal aliens expressly required by the U.S. Constitution? On its face, the answer is ‘no.’

“The 14th Amendment confers citizenship through naturalization or by birth to persons ‘subject to the jurisdiction’ of the United States, but provides no guidance on when an alien is to be regarded as subject to U.S. jurisdiction.

“One might say the practice has become policy without becoming law.”

The 14th Amendment was passed in 1868 in the aftermath of the Civil War, and its Citizenship Clause was intended to ensure that freed slaves would be recognized as U.S. citizens.

“There is simply no direct evidence that Congress wished to confer citizenship on the children of temporary or illegal visitors, but there is some evidence that they did not,” Feere observes.

Sen. Jacob Howard, a Michigan Republican who debated a resolution that would become the Citizenship Clause, limited citizenship by birth by stating in 1866: “This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the Government of the United States.”

Feere also notes that an illegal alien is, under law, a citizen of a foreign country and therefore subject to that nation’s jurisdiction, and the authors of the Citizenship Clause intended that “jurisdiction as to the child would be imputed from the status of the parents.”

He maintains, then, that a child born in America to illegal aliens is not “subject to the jurisdiction” of the United States, and therefore is not entitled to citizenship.

John Eastman, a professor at the Chapman University School of Law, said in a media conference in August that illegal immigrants are not subject to U.S. jurisdiction in the sense that they cannot be drafted into the American military or tried for treason against the United States.

Their children would share that status, via citizenship in their parents’ nation or nations of birth – and so would not be eligible for a U.S. passport, even if born on American soil, according to Eastman’s statements reported by the Christian Science Monitor.

Furthermore, Eastman said, federal courts have upheld the right of Congress to regulate naturalization policies over and above the basic constitutional guarantee.

Therefore, CIS report author Feere concludes, “Some eminent scholars and jurists have concluded that it is within the power of Congress to define the scope of the Citizenship Clause through legislation and that birthright citizenship for the children of temporary visitors and illegal aliens could likely be abolished by statute without amending the Constitution.”

To that end, last year Nathan Deal, then a Georgia Republican in the House, introduced legislation — which has nearly 100 co-sponsors — that would limit birthright citizenship to persons born in the United States to at least one parent who is either a U.S. citizen, a permanent resident alien, or an alien performing active duty in the armed forces. 

PopsiclesandThrowbacks --- 16 years ago -

What do you all think? 

PopsiclesandThrowbacks --- 16 years ago -

Ellis Island in NY used to be open, whoever wanted to come could, and they became legal US citizens, legal tax paying citizens. Now it's all about money which has in turn backfired and caused the problem we now have with illegals and costs that is such a big issue.

I feel like America was made to be a place everyone was/is welcomed. I feel like whoever wants to be a citizen should be. In saying that, the US shouldn't make it so expensive and hard and people would legally become citizens. Once you are a citizen you pay taxes.

I don't really see the problem as far as immigration, I see the issue as becoming a citizen is more about making money and the greed is costing Americans even more problems.

Think about it, we are all (down the line) from somewhere else....none of us would be here, or should I say very few, if we had to pay 5000 each to become citizens. 

YoUr MoM --- 16 years ago -

I feel like America was made to be a place everyone was/is welcomed. I feel like whoever wants to be a citizen should be. In saying that, the US shouldn't make it so expensive and hard and people would legally become citizens. Once you are a citizen you pay taxes.
Really? So if we roll up to another country and want to be a citizen there you think they won't make it harder then we do? 

PopsiclesandThrowbacks --- 16 years ago -

But see, going back to the start, America was made to be a place for everyone, everyone was welcomed......I'm not talking about other countries.

I don't feel as if I have any more right(s) than another to be an American.

Let's make is easy and it will be done legally. That will solve the issue of hoe "illegals don't pay taxes" bc once your a citizen you do and you can contribute...done....easy lol 

YoUr MoM --- 16 years ago -

Not if they don't fu*king work!!!!!! Then they roll into dhs and suck some more money from who? TAX PAYERS.....Imma say this if you gonna get assistance food and such you should have a job and PAY TAXS........OH and another thing why is it most all jobs drug test ur azz, yet for cash and food assistance they don't? 

~Ole Timer~ --- 16 years ago -

Now, I want to know. Why is it that from the time I was born, we didn't have all these illegals. Its like this country just doesn't give a crap about anything.

It takes action, not just writing.

Protesting. and standing up for what you believing in what you stand for, teaching you children to do the same. How else can this generation survive?

We want this crap to stop. Then do more then type! JMO 

PopsiclesandThrowbacks --- 16 years ago -

Not if they don't fu*king work!!!!!! Then they roll into dhs and suck some more money from who? TAX PAYERS.....Imma say this if you gonna get assistance food and such you should have a job and PAY TAXS........OH and another thing why is it most all jobs drug test ur azz, yet for cash and food assistance they don't?


OMG....I'm right there with ya!! I feel the same way.

However, lots of undocumented people work. Lots of US Companies hire them because they don't have to pay them benefits and such...It would be nice if they wern't undocumented so we could tax them on it..... 

PopsiclesandThrowbacks --- 16 years ago -

Now, I want to know. Why is it that from the time I was born, we didn't have all these illegals. Its like this country just doesn't give a crap about anything.


What are you talking about? We grant "asylum" to anyone who asks, always have. Anyone except for Mexico and South American's. The borders were open until in recent history. Shoot Texas and California were part of Mexico until the US took them for non payment for loans, much like what China is going to do to us. You have people who have mothers and fathers are still alive from when there wasn't an issue to come from Mexico and live in the US, from when parts of the US were Mexico's and now all of the sudden it's a problem.

We need immigration reform. 

PopsiclesandThrowbacks --- 16 years ago -


Protesting. and standing up for what you believing in what you stand for, teaching you children to do the same. How else can this generation survive?

We want this crap to stop. Then do more then type! JMO



So why is that you feel your family was anymore entitled to migrate here than someone elses?

The only people who actually have RIGHTS to this country are those indigenous to it, that's right NATIVE AMERICANS. When the East came here, these villages were raped and pillaged and were taken over and called America. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Bragg Underground